Frugal Diaper Washing: Cutting Down On Detergent

Catherine McDiarmid-Watt | Saturday, August 31, 2019 | 0 comments
Rate this post:

Image: Reusable diapers, by Michael Coté on Flickr

My husband made some more of our laundry soap last night, and I did some calculations. 

Over the last month, I've been experimenting and discovered I can use much less than I used to and still get great results.

My recipe uses one bar of Fels Naptha, grated (about 2 cups), and 1 cup washing soda. The total yield is roughly 52 cups detergent. Since I only use 3/4 c. per load, I end up with nearly 70 loads.

So, that means each load contains roughly 2/3 teaspoon washing soda, and 1 1/3 t. soap.

Now, the reason for all this? I've been reading washing soda causes pilling for many people, yet I haven't had a problem. Perhaps this is because I have hard water; I don't know.

Image: Laundry Soap Kit - Fels Naptha 4 bars, 20 Mule Team Borax Natural Laundry Booster, and Arm + Hammer Super Washing Soda by BORAX
Laundry Soap Kit
However, I also wonder if it is because of the tiny amount I use in each load? I see people using anywhere from 2 Tbs. per load to 1/2 cup per load.

And the same thing applies to the soap - I read of people using 1/4 c. grated per load, yet I get great results with just 1 1/3 t. soap.

Now, Fels Naptha IS a concentrated soap, but I wonder if I'd get the same results if the soap were not pre-dissolved, together with the washing soda, as it is when I make my soap recipe.

It may be the soap does it's job better when first dissolved together with a boosting agent (the washing soda).

Image: Clutter's Last Stand: It's Time To De-junk Your Life! | Paperback: 262 pages | by Don Aslett (Author), Tad Herr (Illustrator). Publisher: Adams Media; 2 edition (April 1, 2005)
Clutter's Last Stand:
It's Time To De-junk Your Life!
I wonder if it isn't so much the washing soda itself causing problems, as the way it is used? Many of you may be familiar with Don Aslett - the cleaning guru?

He talks of how many people misuse cleaning solutions, by using them in the wrong proportions, and not applying them correctly.

There's the idea of if a little bit works, a lot will work better, and Mr. Aslett disputes this, by explaining the products are designed to work a certain way, and if we overuse them, they will either not do their job properly, or will even cause damage.

I wonder if what actually causes diapers to pill is TOO MUCH washing soda?

By the way - I've been washing my diapers this way for 16 months now, and not one has any pilling. Maybe I've been lucky; maybe it's because of the hard water (although it isn't excessively hard); I really don't know.

But I thought I'd throw these thoughts out there - anyone else has any input on this?

Thanks to Amy for this Frugal Baby Tip!



About Catherine: I have been writing my Frugal Baby Tips since 1982, when I was a young divorced mom of two - for my baby product company, Born to Love. I am now mom to three grown up sons, and a grandma - and happily married to a wonderful man. We have rescued two little dogs, Denny and Dexter - and a rescue cat, Bella.

Taking care of baby and mom needs naturally, does not have to cost a whole lot of money! Money-saving tips on diapering, diaper washing, safety, sling and baby carriers, toys, clothing, nursing, menstrual needs, traveling with kids, and more!

If you have Frugal Baby Tips to share, we want to hear them! It might even get published!

Find Catherine on Google+ - Join us on Facebook - Follow us on Pinterest


Catherine encourages positive comments and suggestions that are helpful to other blog readers. Help keep this a fun place to visit and help all of us save money and get more frugal baby tips!

NOTE: Comments are moderated - just to stop the spambots - and so may take up to a few hours to be approved.

Catherine reserves the right to review, edit, refuse or delete any comment.

Popular Posts